The quality of the player only reflects their history and experience. It doesn't predict how they will perform in this league...so many variables (line mate chemistry, execution of tactics, fitness levels etc)
Former Devil Charles Linglet had a fantastic resume/CV. It didn't make him the top player in the league that season.
Any excuse for a bit of stat diving on Chucky and that 18/19 side. Although annoyingly the EIHL stat page and EP differ in their numbers so I have gone with EP...
(admittedly these may have some errors as I've added them up from the 2018/19 stats page and checked each player against each competition, so I may have misread somewhere. But ChatGPT wasn't having a great time providing accurate numbers!)
In 2018/19 Linglet put up 96 points across all competitions (league, challenge cup, playoffs, and CHL). Close behind him were Martin (90), and Fournier and Mike Hedden (both 84). Darcy Murphy at Giants put up 101, although he wasn't in the CHL (where Chuck put up 2 points) he was in the Conti Cup where he got 9 points against lower quality opponents.
Domestically it was Linglet 94-92 Murphy
So was he the best that year....arguably.
Of note, the top scorers for the Devils across the post-Covid seasons across all domestics and European competitions were:
2021/22 - Brodie Reid (77)
2022/23 - Cole Sanford (84)
2023/24 - Marcus Crawford (74)
2024/25 - Josh MacDonald (79)
2025/26 - Kristoff Kontos (66) - albeit with no European competition