The goalies were some of the best around? I respect your opinions but they were nowhere near it.
He wasn’t the only player to have put up north of 150 points in a 30 game season.
You mentioned Hotham, Fournier and Cox as comparators. I think each of these would break 200 points with ease in those days.
It was entertaining for sure, but the standard was very bad compared to the ISL and the product we had pre covid.
I so want to believe that prime Dougie could transition and I’m sure he’d be a good player in this league today.
But i don’t think he’d have a hope of going coast to coast like he could in that era.
I’m just disputing his place as top Devil of all time, not that I don’t rate what he did in that era
But this is an argument that's been had about how past greats would get on in the current NHL. For my money a Gretzky, an orr or a Howe would thrive in any era. Current players have benefitted for better strength and fitness training, better equipment, better coaching and in game analysis.
You're undoubtedly right that any of those players would dominate in that past era. There thing is, if MC was 26 in today's league he would have had those current benefits.
Also let's not forget that he and Shannon hope went undrafted due to the smaller size of the NHL in those days. I suspect that wouldn't be the case with the bigger size of pro hockey and the improved scouting that exists today.
I think that the qualities that would allow a player to thrive in any era are heart and determination. MC had those in spades. I don't ever recall an occasion where he didn't give 100% for the devils.